Truck Wreck Attorney Insight: 9 Places Critical Evidence Hides After a Semi Crash
If you only remember one thing, make it this: in an 18-wheeler case, the winner usually finds the evidence first.
Most blogs on semi truck wrecks read like a brochure. This one is different. If you were hit by a tractor-trailer, here is where the case is really won or lost. These are the systems, files, and roadside breadcrumbs that can flip liability, increase case value, and explain what happened in those few seconds on I-40, I-25, or I-27 across Texas and New Mexico.
Quick takeaways
- Trucking cases are about data, maintenance, and loading as much as driving errors.
- The most valuable evidence often expires or gets overwritten within days.
- A fast preservation letter can be the difference between a fair result and a finger-pointing stalemate.
Why 18-wheeler crashes are not “big car wrecks”
Car cases focus on drivers. Semi cases add the motor carrier, the dispatcher, the shipper or loader, the maintenance vendor, and sometimes a broker. Federal safety rules apply, trucks carry telematics you do not see in passenger vehicles, and loads must be secured so they can survive hard braking, cornering, and wind. When a crash happens, the question is not only who steered. It is who planned, maintained, and loaded.
The 9 hidden evidence sources that decide truck cases
- ECM/EDR and telematics data Engine Control Module and Event Data Recorder downloads capture speed, throttle, brake application, fault codes, and sometimes hard-brake or stability control events. Many fleets also run vendor telematics that log harsh events and GPS breadcrumbs. These systems can overwrite quickly, which is why early preservation is critical. Learn what EDRs are meant to record from NHTSA.
- ELD hours-of-service logs Electronic logging devices track drive time, on-duty status, and break compliance. Fatigue cases live here. Compare the logs with fuel, toll, and GPS data to spot falsification. See the regulatory framework at FMCSA Hours of Service.
- Dashcams and driver-facing video Forward cameras often tell the whole story. Driver-facing video can show distraction or drowsiness. Many systems loop and overwrite after a short window unless an event is flagged. Ask for raw files and the vendor’s retention policy.
- Driver qualification file Hiring record, road test, medical card, training, prior violations, and post-accident testing. This file helps prove negligent hiring or retention when patterns were ignored.
- Maintenance and inspection records Brake stroke measurements, tire condition, service intervals, and out-of-service history matter. A clean pre-trip box on a DVIR does not end the inquiry. Compare shop tickets, roadside inspections, and code faults.
- Load securement proof Bills of lading, photos at the dock, and policies on tie-down counts and anchor points. Inadequate securement can make a safe maneuver dangerous. Review cargo rules at FMCSA Cargo Securement.
- Carrier safety history Crash frequency, violations, and inspections can show patterns. Start with the public snapshot at FMCSA SAFER Company Snapshot and follow with full discovery for context.
- Third-party breadcrumbs Weigh station passes, toll tags, fuel receipts, dispatch texts, and dock logs can confirm timelines and contradict “I was parked” stories on I-40 through the Panhandle, I-25 between Las Cruces and Raton, or I-27 between Lubbock and Amarillo.
- Scene-level physics Lane position, debris fields, yaw marks, and crush profiles explain speed, braking, and angles. Pair this with ECM timestamps to build a second-by-second reconstruction.
What to do in the first 7 days
- Photograph all vehicles, cargo, and the roadway. Include wide shots and close-ups of tie-downs, strap winches, and brake components if visible.
- Save your phone photos and videos in a redundant place. Do not rely on a single device.
- Document every symptom and medical visit. Gaps in care will be used against you.
- Avoid recorded statements to any insurer before you understand the data picture.
- Have a truck-savvy team send a preservation letter for ECM, ELD, camera, and maintenance records before automatic overwrites occur.
Why corridors like I-40, I-25, and I-27 see complex crashes
These routes carry heavy interstate freight, mixed traffic, and fast weather changes. Crosswinds on the Llano Estacado, dust near construction zones, and tight interchanges compound risk. The cases that resolve well usually connect weather, load, speed, and dispatch decisions with data, not assumptions.
How a truck wreck attorney builds leverage
- Lock down data and video from every device in the chain of custody.
- Cross-check logs with independent time stamps to expose rule violations.
- Map maintenance gaps to braking distance and stopping performance.
- Trace load plans to securement rules and real-world forces in the crash.
- Present a clear, time-synced storyboard that a jury can follow.
Free Consultation with Attorney Dean Boyd
If you or a loved one was hit by a semi on I-40, I-25, I-27, or anywhere in Texas or New Mexico, talk to a team that knows where the evidence hides and how to keep it. Call Attorney Dean Boyd today for a free consultation.